On Tuesday, the “Laguna Beach” stars appeared cozily snuggled up together in a photo posted to Cavallari’s Instagram page.
“2004 or 2020?!” she captioned the image, a nod back to when the duo dated in high school while starring on the MTV reality series.
Fans of “Laguna Beach” can’t forget that Cavallari and Colletti’s relationship woes were the height of dramatic TV from 2004 to 2006: They spawned a rivalry between Cavallari and co-star/classmate Lauren Conrad and led viewers to discuss whether they were pro-Kristin or pro-“LC.”
Apparently, the pair was not rekindling the former flame between them — rather, Cavallari was simply visiting her hometown, TMZ reported. And, in fairness to Cavallari, the caption holds up: The two of them do look a whole lot like they did nearly 15 years ago.
Assuming we can’t go back, back to the beginning of Cavallari and Colletti’s relationship, the reunion photo still sent many “Laguna Beach” fans into a tizzy ― including fellow MTV reality TV star Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi:
Fans on Twitter were also beside themselves about the Colletti-Cavallari 2020 moment:
Calling all HuffPost superfans!
Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost’s next chapter